Work From Home Jobs Sunderland
Teaching/Learning Gender and Sex Through Systems Thinking in Asian and African Philosophy
By Josephine Acosta-Pasricha, PhD
This is an academic paper presented twice in Asian Philosophical Conferences, recently rethought and reframed, reinvented and reengineered through Systems Thinking, for use by philosophy professors teaching feminism, gender studies and women studies.It is now specially relevant with the establishment of UN Women, the UN Entity for gender equality and empowerment of women and girls by January 2011. Michelle Bachelet, president of Chile 2006-2010, a doctor of medicine, defense specialist and divorced/single mother of three children, is the first UN Women head, appointed as undersecretary general of the United Nations on 15 September 2010.The Millennium Summit, which came out with Millennium Development Goals in 2000, has celebrated its 10th anniversary on 20-22 September 2010 at the United Nations in New York. The heads of state/government and the representatives of 192 countries attended and assessed what their countries have done in ten years and what they still have to do for the next five to ten years. US President Barack Obama said in 2009: "We will support the Millennium Development Goals and approach next year's summit with a Global Plan to make them a reality and set our own sights to the eradication of extreme poverty in our time."At the United Nations in 2010, President Obama presented a New US Global Development Policy that is founded on three criteria of winner countries -- good governance, economic stability and results/outcomes. This is "soft power" in action -- the ability to set and attain goals without the use of force.UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon also distributed "A Global Strategy for Women's and Children's Health" - a strategic handbook that contains policies, processes, programs, best practices and actions to help countries cut maternal mortality and infant mortality by two thirds by 2015.Policies are rules for selecting any means towards a goal or defining function. Processes are sequences of actions directed to goals. Programs are combinations of actions directed to a particular goal. Practises are repeated actions. Actions are one time choices of means. (Russell Ackoff, et. al., 1976)"Stand up, take action and make noise for the MDGs" also happened around the world on 17-19 September 2010.So "Wake me up when the data is over" (Lori Silverman, 2006).Wake me up when the Millennium Document 2010 has been signed, which promises US $26 Billion for maternal and infant health care for 2011 alone, and US $40 Billion for the next five years to the Global FundThen, we can do Story-Telling with MDG warriors on the ground as in People Power People for change management and transformational leadership.
Teaching/Learning Gender and Sex Through Systems Thinking in Asian and African Philosophy
By Josephine Acosta-Pasricha, PhD
visiting scholar in Systems Thinking
Organizational Dynamics, SAS Graduate Studies
University of Pennsylvania
Copyright 2010![]() |
| Happy Canada Day, July 1, 2011Update: Kate might have a baby girl! |
![]() |
| Diplomacyby Design(er): Maple leaf fascinator, red and white colors of Canada, dress wrap by Reiss |
![]() |
| Royal purple jerseygown by Issa London |
![]() |
| At BAFTA in Hollywood, Kate stuns in a lavender Alexander McQueen gown |
![]() |
William wins in Polo at Santa Barbara, gets the trophy and a kiss. ![]() |
| Kate, Duchess of Cambridge dons on chef outfit in a cooking workshop at the Institute of Tourism. |
![]() |
| The New Romantics: The double kiss, the dress, the Wedding of the 21st century |
INTRODUCTION
The metaphor here is when a leaf in the Himalaya rangesflaps its wings, like a butterfly in the Amazon jungle, it can conceivably lead to storms in the South China Sea. The Butterfly Effect in Systems Thinkingmeans that "the flapping of a butterfly wing in Brazil could stir the air that causes chain reaction of greater and greater proportions, and ultimately results in a raging storm over Europe". (Daryl R. Conner, Leading at the Edge of Chaos. New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc., 1990, p.22) The butterfly effect means that a simple thing, like a royal wedding orthe first overseas trip to Canada and the United States of a royal couple like Prince William and Catherine, Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, can have chain reactions of bigger and greater proportions.Liberian President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, Liberian peace activist Leymah Gbowee and Yemeni human rights activist and journalist Tawakkul Karman -- three outstanding women from Africa and the Middle East and their winning the 2011 Nobel Peace Price also have great chain reactions of big and great proportions for all women in Africa and the world.
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in her visit to Busan, Korea to attend the Fourth High Level Forum on Aid Effectiveness, says that nations which invest in women's employment, health and education tend to have more economic growth. She suggests that countries put women at the center of development efforts.Clinton then proceeds to visit Myanmar and meet Aung San Suu Kyi, pro democracy icon.
![]() |
| US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton meets Myanmar democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi and it becomes the earthshaking event of half a century. Change is coming. Change is. |
Events can have a great impact on the environmental, economic and geopolitical systems. Hopefully, it can be life giving! To the youth to women and girls, to the marginalized, deprived and disabled.
The metaphor of conversation here between them and the world is also a rich image to understand the complexity of the human person, human systems, and complex adaptive systems that can unite and differentiate countries and peoples. It has great potential for discourse democracy and peace. (Michael Cavanaugh, "Coaching from a Systemic Perspective: A Complex Adaptive Conversation" in Evidence Based Coaching Handbook, Eds. Dianne R. StoberandAnthony M. Grant. Canada: John Wiley and Sons, 2006, pp. 313-354)
Nobel Peace Prize 2011
![]() |
| Liberian President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf |
![]() |
| Yemeni human rights activist and journalist Tawakkul Karman |
![]() |
| Liberian peace activist Leymah Gbowee |
Statement of the Problem
The problem of this paper is how philosophy can promote gender equality and empowerment of girls and women, as mandated by the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) of the United Nations -- through Systems Thinking.
In September 2000, the Millennium Summit was the largest gathering of world leaders at the United Nations, participated in by 150 heads of State or heads of Governments.
The Millennium Summit addressed major global challenges, in an agenda for reducing poverty, its causes and manifestations.
The Millennium Summit came out with the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) or global targets that the leaders of the world set in the Millennium Declaration.
Such as how to pull 1.2 billion people in 2000 out of extreme poverty, how to reverse the spread of HIV/AIDS, and how to protect the environment.
The most well known target of the Millennium Declaration is the pledge to cut the number of people living in absolute poverty, which according to the United Nations definition of the term, poverty -- are people living on less than US one dollar per day. UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan in 2000 enumerated worrisome statistics (world citizens would considerthese are shameful/shameless numbers, thatresult ina "Politics of Disgust") as follows: 1.2 billion people live with less than US $ 1.00 a day 800 million are malnourished 153million children are below the ideal weight 115 million children are not enrolled in school with 97 % of children in developing countries 64 % of world's illiterate population are women 80 % of world's refugee population are women 60 % of children not enrolled in primary school arefemale Every year, 10 million children die of preventable diseases Every year, 500, 000 women die when giving birth or during pregnancy In Sub Saharan Africa, 1 in 16 women die in these conditions while in OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development) countries, this same proportion is only 1 in every 2, 800 women In year 2000 alone, 22 million people died of HIV/AIDS, 13 million childrenlost their parents to HIV/AIDS virus, 40 million people live with HIV/AIDS Annually, 300 million people are sick of malaria Annually, 60 million people are infected with tuberculosis In year 2000, 1 billion people in developing countries did not have access to drinking water 2.4 billion people did not have access to sanitary services 14 % of the world's population in developed world, produces 44 % of the yearly CO2 total. Kofi Annan, who was UN Secretary-General from 1997-2006, and chair of African Progress Panel now, has concluded that US $ 100 Billion are necessary to achieve the MDGs.He has said that 0.5 % of GDP of developed countries is necessary for raising that amount. The Millennium Declaration wants to reduce absolute poverty by one half, bring down mortality of children under five years old by two thirds, and mortality of mothers dying in childbirth by three fourths, by the year 2015. It is 2010 and the expected global outcomes have not been reached, the progress is uneven, bothby developed and developing economies, richandpoor countries. The gaps between goals and key result areas are wide; the obstacles/blockages are stiff; many women and children are falling in the cracks. Vietnam is phenomenal inthat it may make all the MDGs! Ghana and Vietnam are the star performers, according to the Overseas Development Institute (ODI). Ten African countries have attained the target of halving poverty levels, ODI adds. Mwandama, Malawi presents the best prototype ofa Millennium Development Village, a live document ofpublic/private partnership, betweenan effective/efficient governmentand an empowered people with the Earth Institute of Columbia University, internationalorganizations and philanthropic donors. But many countries lag behind specially inwomen's problems. For example, the single biggest lag is in universal secondary education for young adolescent girls; because, there is no funding targetted for this. While the most lagging MDG is safe childbirth. Maternal deaths in pregnancy and childbirth, whichhaveknown scientific solutions, still hound the poorest of the poor. Trending is the Feminization of Poverty! Extreme poverty has the face of Women and Girls. http://mdgs.un.org/unsd/mdg/Default.aspx Why? How come? So what now? It is about time to evolve from the First Order of change to the Second Order of change, from a frame-makingdevelopmental focus to a frame-breaking transformation, from the quantitative numbers game to a qualitative human side of change management and transformational leadership. First Order change occurs within a given Form which remains unchanged. While Second Order change is one whose occurrence changes the Form itself. First Order change is change within the system. Second Order change is change of the system. First Order change is development. Second Order change is transformation. (Paul Bate, Strategies for Cultural Change. Oxford: Buttterworth Heinemann, 1994, 2002, p. 163) This paper would like to recommend three Breakthrough Action Plans to be doneon available research grants, with great innovation and creativity: (I would need 24 K to 60 K research granteach year until 2015to accomplishthese. Are there any takers out there?) 1) Perhaps, there is a need to bridge the gap between theMillennium Development Goals and an Idealized Design through Systems Thinking as innovated by Russell Ackoff, but with a focus on the women's perspective. 2) Language is also a means of dealing with problems in the world. Perhaps, through "Communicative Action" or communicating through action as taught by Jurgen Habermas, and within the context of universal education in "Deliberative Democracy" or Discourse Democracy as taught by Jurgen Habermas, John Rawls and Amy Gutmann, Ph. D. in Political Sciencefrom Harvard University and president of the University of Pennsylvania, we can increase understanding and learning, innovation and creativity, mutuality and respecttoattain peace, truth and justice. 3) The "Theory of Capabilities" applied in economics by Nobel Laureate Amatya Sen, and in philosophy by Martha Nussbaum, Ph. D. in Philosophy from Harvard University and professor at the University of Chicago, mayextend insights through Gender Analysis into better quality of life assessments in development/transformational economics and international/national policymaking.Nussbaum has written "Women and Human Development", a framework-breaking seminal work, on women's issues, questions and problems.
. ![]() |
| Dr. Amy Gutmann, president of the University of Pennsylvania |
![]() |
| Graca Machel |
![]() |
| Graca Machel and her Scholars |
![]() |
| Nelson Mandela and wife, Graca Machel |
Michelle Bachelet, president of Chile 2006-2010, a doctor of medicine, defense specialist and divorced/single mother of three children, has been appointed asthe first head of UN Women, second highest in rank as undersecretary general of the United Nations on September 15, 2010. Michelle Bachelet brings with her to the negotiating table a global network, an indomitable will power, competencies and achievements, specially in pushing the envelope wide on gender issues and women's rights. As the first female president of Chile, and evenin South America, she has been cutting edge successbecause of the following: 1. a law giving women the right to breastfeed at work 2. a law stiffening penalties for men failing payment of alimony 3. nurseries established for infants and children, domestic violence centers established for women and children 4. equal numbers of women and men serving in top government jobs, including the cabinet 5. women getting admitted for the first time to the Chilean Naval Academy The crowning glory of her presidency, however, is "Chile Crece Contigo" or "Chile Grows With You, " a childhood development program seen from thelens of social investment.Her progressive policy of pragmatic socialism has reduced social inequality, extreme poverty and maternal/infant mortality and diseases, at the same time encouraged a free market economy, public-private partnership and a global commodities boon. Her Systems Thinking emphasizes "Social Cohesion" where all members, men and women, adults and children, government and people participate in the planning, action and development process. It is worth reviewing her Four Main Principles, as they converge with the philosophy of Systems Thinking: 1. Human Rights -- All children have the right to develop to the maximum individual potential. 2. Social Participation -- The families of children participate in the initial design phase to include their needs and wants. 3. Equity -- Universal action for all children of similar age. 4. Social Safety Nets -- Free pre-natal and post-natal care, a mandatory paid maternal leave, State-subsidized day care centers, free childcare to working families, scholarships to adolescent mothers. As a result, Chile hasbeen included in the Human Development Index of UNDP as 38th and ahead of all Latin America. Chile has also become the first South American country to be accepted into the OECD, or the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, composed of the world's top 31 industrialized economies. "Social Justice for women and poor people" is the lifelong call to action of Michelle Bachelet. Global Colloquium of University Presidents On April 4, 2011, the Fifth Global Colloquium of University Presidents, "Empowering Women to Change theWorld, What Universities and the United Nations Can Do"was hosted by Dr. Amy Gutmann, president of the University of Pennsylvania. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon was keynote speaker. About 25 university presidents, accompanied by faculty experts, came from around the world. UN Undersecretary-General and UN Women Director Michelle Bachelet also attended andgave the keynote speechon April 5, 2011. Ban Ki-moon used Story-telling, the latest trend, as a tool for change management and transformational leadership. He opened a Johari window about himself. In so doing, his speech became moreTolstoyan. Ban Ki-moon told the story of how in his childhoodin the 1950's, he wrote to UN Secretary General Dag Hammarksjold about the status of children during the Korean war. Now that he is secretary general, he hopes that no children would need to complain in the same manner.Ban Ki-moon said, however, that there are many children around the world writing to him. Ban Ki-moon also told the story of how the United Nations sent an all-women Indian police to Liberia for a six month peace-keeping stint. The victims of injustice, specially of violence and sexual harassment, opened up to them. "The women felt safer and more empowered to complain about abuses, " he said.But surprisingly, the Liberian women also became inspired to apply for jobs and join the police force. Ban Ki-moon has announced two heartwarming initiatives. One, is his intention to increase women workers in the United Nations. There isalready egalitarianism andequal opportunity for women and men in the top management; but, he is working for an increase of women to about 40% in middle management. Two, is the establishment of the UN Academic Impact for partnership between UN and the universities. "There are already 600 members from 100 countries, universities and institutions of higher education and research, " he said. He wants to bridge informationto policy. There isa need forresearchin gender equality and women empowerment, specially in data gathering, analysis and management, concepts, definitions, methods and tools for organization, change management and transformative leadership. ![]() |
| UN Women Director Michelle Bachelet and UST Prof. Dr. Josephine AcostaPasricha |
![]() |
| Michelle Bachelet and US President Barack Obama |
![]() |
| Prince Charles and Michelle Bachelet |
- The wholemay have one or more defining functions. Thus, a system has one or more functions. A system may also be part of one or many larger containing systems; its functions being the roles it plays with these larger systems.
- Properties and behavior of each element and the way the elementaffects the whole depends on properties and behavior of at least one other element of the set. Each part in the set can affect the functions of the whole. No part has an independent effect on the whole. Although all systems also have appendices which do not affect the properties of the whole.
- There is a subset of parts that is sufficient in one or more environments for carrying out the defining function of the whole. Each of these parts is necessary but insufficient for carrying out this defining function. These parts are essential parts of the system. Without any one of them, the system cannot carry out its defining function. Most systems also contain nonessential parts that affect their functioning, but not their defining function. A system that requires certain environmental conditions in order to carry out its defining function is an open system. A system that could carry out its function in every environment would be completely independent of its environment and therefore be a closed system.The environment of a system consists of things that can affect the properties and performance of the system; but over which, it has no control. The part of environment that a system can influence, but not control, is said to be transactional. The part of environment, that can neither be influenced nor controlled, is said to be contextual.
- The way that each essential part affects the systems behavior or properties depends on the behavior or properties of at least one other essential part of the system. The essential parts of a system form a connected set, that is, a path can be found between any two parts. No essential part of a system has an independent effect on the system of which it is a part. The essential parts of a system necessarily interact, either directly or indirectly.
- The effect of any subset of essential parts on the system as a whole depends on the behavior of at least one other subset. Like the individual parts of a system, no subset of parts of a system has an independent effect on it. If the parts of an entity do not interact, they form an aggregation, not a system.
In my whole life of almost 60 years, 40 of which were spent as a journalist, I have never gone inside a red-light district.
I have seen the famous red light district of Amsterdam, where the women are on display in glass windows. But it was only from a safe distance inside a moving car.
I have seen the women for sale in the streets of Bangkok. Also from a distance.
I have walked up and down Ermita in Manila, Pasay, Makati, and seen the women of the night sitting by the doorways of bars and parlors and other entertainment establishments. Again, from a distance.
In Kamagayan, Cebu, however, Ihave goneinside the red-light district with social workers. I have met and talked with the prostitutes, the pimps, the mama-sans.
The only people I did not see were the owners and their politician-protectors.
14 to 65!
The stories of most prostitutes are the same, they are young, well-protected daughters of decent fathers, mostly poor farmers and fishermen in the small towns of our country. They have reached only grade or high school. Very few are in college.
Most have run away from home, because ofabsolute poverty and the alluring promises of a recruiter to be given decent work as waitress or saleslady in the city.
But you can establish a profile of the Filipino prostitute. When asked how old they are, they always say they are 18 all the way to 24. But you look at their faces and bodies and many of them look like minors. Their true ages range from 14 up to 65. Yes, sexagenarians are also in demand.
They never tell you their real ages. Just as they never tell you where they come from and their real names. The names of the same persons change every night.
At the very outset, here are women living a life of lies, lying to others and lying to themselves. You look into their eyes, and you see hurt and the woundedness of Filipino women without a positive self-image, without a sense of self-worth, and without self-respect. There is an identity crisis in each and every girl.
Who can accept such a sordid life in such a sordid profession?
Cebu is the oldest city in the country, the exact place where Ferdinand Magellan discovered the Philippines for the West, and where Lapu-Lapu killed Magellan on April 27, 1521. Cebu is where the cross of Christianity was first planted and the image of the Sto. Nio was given to Queen Juliana.
Barangay Kamagayan in Cebu, is the oldest red-light district in the Philippines.
Welcome to the maze
Archived records speak of Kamagayan district as early as 1906.
Periodical records report it as a prostitution district as early as 1920. And it is plausible, because most prostitution districts in the world, from ancient Greece up to today's modern metropolis, are located at the piers or at the end of the train line.
Kamagayan used to be the end of the train station.
Barangay Kamagayan, which has a barangay center and even a health center that displays prominently information on HIV/AIDs and STD, is composed of three blocks, bordered by the streets of Junquera, P. del Rosario, Jakosalem and Sanciangco. Junquera has been known as the street of prostitution as early as 1920.
Junquera is a one way street, but at night, taxis and cars can go against the traffic into the barangay.
Demographically speaking, there are about 42 casas or prostitution dens here, with about 42 mama-sans or den mothers. As of today, there are 35. They are older women, oftentimes dressed in dusters and playing cards.
There are 60 to 80 pimps working in one night, those who negotiate with the men for the girls. There are certain rules to follow in the negotiation. When a foreigner arrives in Cebu, the taxi driver may ask if the foreigner needs a girl for a night. If the guest agrees, he is brought into Kamagayan, a slum or squatter area, in the same taxi.
The pimps cover the four streets, together with street watchers. The first pimp that the guest or taxi driver talks to owns the negotiation. So the pimps do not fight over the same commercial transactions.
The girls sit on plastic monoblock benches strewn all over the barangay, in street corners, in front of houses or casas, and in the small unpaved plaza. I have also sat on one of those plastic chairs, which is really a childs chair!
When the taxi enters the small plaza clearing, the girls line up.
There can be 10 to 20, or 50 to 70 girls in the chorus line. On heavy days, there can be 250 girls. The cheaper girls are in the entry points of the barangay. The more beautiful ones, the more expensive ones are inside the depths of the barangay.
The headlights of the taxi flood over the girls in the line-up; then, the customer, from inside the taxi, chooses his girl. The girl may go with the customer to his pension house, motel, five-star hotel, or rent any of the casa rooms or cubicles in the barangay.
In a place called City Center, which is actually a market during the day, that turns into a prostitution house for the night, there are cubicles for rent for only P20 to P30 short time. The cubicles are as small as a confessional box, with only a single mattress on the muddy floor. The walls are made of thin unpainted plywood. You can hear whatever is happening inside.
Nauseating sight
The cubicle is the most nauseating sight that an advocate for womens rights and against child abuse could ever see. Even I have never felt the same revulsion before, and I have seen the ancient excavated prostitution houses in Pompeii, Italy, with pornographic paintings on the walls, and chairs and beds based on stone.
How is RA 6393, the law against trafficking of women and children applied in this case? Or RA 9208, the Anti-Trafficking in Persons Act of 2003?How can the latest foreign financial aid against trafficking of humans abolish this abomination?
On ordinary days, there are 100, 300 to 500 prostitutes here. One girl can cost from P300 to P500. But the price can go down to a measly P50 to P100. The first-class prostitutes, who in fact do not sit here, or join the line are priced at P15, 000 to P70, 000.
The official share of this payment from P50 to P500 is 25 percent for the girls, 25 percent for the pimp and 25 percent for the mama-san.
The girls do not get their payment, though. It is listed on paper, and used as debt payment for the food, lodging, clothing, make-up, medicine or drugs that the girls are given. The interest rate is worse than five-six. If the girl has no customer, she is not given food. There are many days, when the girls complain that they have not eaten for the day.
After dinner in the middle of the night, we go around Kamagayan and distribute food to the girls. But they would rather ask for condoms.
The girls are also forbidden to talk to strangers, even to the customers, and specially to social workers. They are fined when they are caught talking to strangers. The fine is charged against their income.
Kamagayan is busy from 8:30 in the evening up to 4:30 at dawn.
Traffic is heavy on certain days. Especially paydays on the 15th and last day of the month. And when there is a convention in Cebu. Even conventions of interdenominational religions are no exemption.
Most of the clients are construction workers in the lower bracket and foreigners in the upper bracket of the economic ladder.
The heaviest traffic is when Americans go on rest and recreation in Cebu. Then, casas all over the country congregate here. And they can buy whole casas from Luzon, or Visayas or Mindanao and transport them over here.
Waiting for Prince Charming
The Cinderella dream of each prostitute, like Pretty Woman, is to be rescued from this dungeon in a tower, by a white knight in shining armor, preferably rich and handsome as Richard Gere. Some foreigners do get them as live-in partners and promise them marriage. To have a live-in prostitute is cheaper than to get a girl every night. For the customer pays only for food and gifts for the girl. But when the girl gets pregnant, she is sent out of the customers house, and beaten up sometimes. Duringthe day, a priest/pastor may be called; because, one of the girls have attempted suicide, or abortion by inserting a needle into her womb. The priest/pastor brings her to the hospital, mindless of the scandal it can cause. After she recovers in the hospital, and on her own free will, the girl may be transferred to a half-way house, given psychotherapy and taught livelihood skills. The girls, specially the minors, invariably scream in the middle of the night in the half-way house. Prostitution is a negativeexperience from which a woman does not completely recover. A 14-year-old girl has already died, beaten up and stabbed by her customer in the casa. The tragedy is not just the meaninglessness of her death, but the fact that nobody knows her real name and where she comes from. Her relatives do not know what happened to her, and so sheis buried incognito. Absolute Poverty has no Face, no mind, no self.As I write this, I put to risk the lives of the girls, the social workers, myself and my editors. Because the knee-jerk reaction of government after such an expos as this, is to raid the red-light district and imprison the girls and the pimps. Never have they caught any owner or a prostitution lord.
The girls may be abused by their casa owners and the police.
The girls will have no business for a few weeks and no food to eat. This is gross injustice.Gender Equality is a human right. A person has the human right to development. But Kamagayan, the red-light district will be quiet.
Second Order of Change
How can an Idealized Design be formedfor the future ofKamagayan and absolutely poor villages like it?
Jeanette V. Loanzon, Doctor in Economics, Rel. Pol, from Philipps University of Marburg in Germany, MBA from the Catholic University of Leuven in Belgium, and Masters on Economics Education from CRC, now the University of Asia and Pacific, has worked with women and girls in poorgrassroots communitiesthrough incubatingsmall and medium scale businesses with them for decades.
Loanzon writes: "Local development forms the roots of an authentic global village. In a developing country, the government needs much from NGOs so that citizens can have more, know more, and be more."
(Pope Paul VI, Populorum Progressio)
Partnerships between government and people, between businesses and community, between academia and community is the "magic silver bullet" here. "It becomesan urgent responsibility for the university, as a center of creativity, to uplift the poor majority." "Helping is an act of restoration (Gronnemeyer in Sachs, 1992)." Loanzon adds. The first need for change management and leadership transformation is education. The Universitycan go into partnership with poor communities, like what Penn did for a black ghetto community in Mantua, likewhat Russell Ackoff did for Mantua, by startinginteractivepartnershipwith Herman Wrice. 1) Help support a development-planning, land use planningand planning implementation group in the less developed area. 2) Establish a resource groupfrom the developed area to assist the indigenous group in the developingarea any way the indigenous group sees fit. The University of Philadelphia has Mantua asa neighboring black community, in a critically depressed, degrading and disadvantaged environment, soasto bereferred as "The Bottom". In 1968, Forrest Adams, a Mantuan, asked the University for help in preparing a letter of request for neighborhood assistance from the city of Philadelphia. The University granted the requestbut askedhim to bring Mantua's principal leader. During the discussions, Herman Wriceagreed to a collaborative interactive partnership with the University of Pennsylvania. This starteddecades of innovative and creative projects for the community. For example: the Mantua Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC)became the umbrella organization of small and medium business enterprises in Mantua. MIDC provided managerial, marketing and financial services. While the University of Pennsylvaniaresearch unit, the Management and Behavioural Science Center of Wharton School, helped with competencies and resources, preparing planning proposals, writing loan proposals, soliciting supportwith the helpof faculty and graduate school students, pro bono. The Architectural and Planning Center also provided the planning for the redevelopment of apartment houses, town houses, a shopping and housing center with a community hall, a Cultural Center that also offers theatre, dance and art classes, and sports facilities for Youth camps. A Medical Center was also built, Dental Services, a Health Mobile that can go to patients, and a Halfway House for drug abusers. Then, schools were built one after another, an Infant Day Center, pre-schools and kindergarden, early elementaryeducation with an open school plan, an integrated elementary school operated by parents, high schools that attract drop outs back into the educational system.A Junior College for the first two yearsof college, does not require an entrance examination; instead an exitinterviewfor a suitable job or an admission into college. The Junior College also offers terminal vocational degrees. A study/work programhas beenestablished between the schools and business companies. Russell Ackoff also invited 21 warring gang leaders of Mantua into an Urban Leadership Training Program, and then toa work/study programat the University of Pennsylvania.Some gang leaders were employed in the Center to work and do field research on the development of their own community with pay. They also studied in a non-degree program, given extensive tutorial, coaching and counselling help, until they could qualifyto apply fora degree program. The leaders put up numerous development projects for the Mantua community. The Center with the help of Wharton faculty assisted in the planning, implementation and assessments of development projects for Mantua. The faculty never said no to any request of the Mantuans and neverimposed any plan of the faculty'sown making either. The protocol was the plans and projects must come from the grassroot level -- a bubble up theory of participative "Deliberative democracy" and community action. Annheuser-Busch Charitable Trust of St. Louis, the Ford Foundation, and University Grantsprovided funding for years. The Busch Center was also established to spread the patterns and principles of Systems Thinking in community development. The result isa black ghetto community, that could be a prototype for change management and transformational leadership, hasleaped from absolute poverty to First Order of change, and thento the Second Order of change. HermanWrice went around to 300 communities, telling the storyof Mantua, inspiringand helping other communities rise from extreme poverty and degradation. (Ackoff, Redesigning the Future, pp. 115-133)
Can the partnership between Mantua andtheManagement and BehavioralScience Center, Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, be replicated in other communitiesand narrow the gap between rich and poorneighborhoods in developed countries? Can the Mantua Cares Project of Organizational Dynamics, SAS Graduate Studies, University of Pennsylvania under Laurence (Larry)Starr, Ph. D. and program director, be replicatedby other communities in developing countries? University of Pennsylvania hasmany ongoing Adopt a Neighborhood Development (A.N.D) projects, the Coalition of Community Schools, programs onschool children's nutrition that earnedUPENN an award as "Number 1 Best Neighbor" among colleges and universities in the United States.The projects and policiesapply Organizational redesign and Interactive planning, and emphasize that both partners, academia and community, businesses and community, must be co-designers, co-teachers and co-actors. Kamagayan is just across one of the oldest universities in Asia, the University of San Carlos, run by the Society of the Divine Word (SVD). The University of Santo Tomas, Pontifical, Royal and Catholic is the oldest university of Asia, founded in1611 and celebrating its quadricentennial in 2011. It is run by the Order of Preachers with the motto, Veritas in Caritate or Truth in Charity. Can the sustainable partnership between academics like Jeannette V. Loanzonof the University of Santo Tomas, and the poor women and girls in rural Pampanga and Mindanao and now in Uganda and Tanzania be reproduced in other parts of the Philippines? Rev. Fr. Rolando de la Rosa, rector magnificus of the University of Santo Tomas has announced the building of 400 houses for the poor to commemorate the quadricentennial. Yes, we can. One university or college or school can adopt two absolutely poor neighborhoods in their area for five years. Communities building communities! C2C. Story Telling to Spark Action Story Telling as communicative action is a most potent tool for change management and transformational leadership. Stephen Denning in his book "The Leader's Guide to Story Telling" (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2005, 360 pp.)enumerates theeight ways of achieving management goals: 1.Sparking Action 2. Communicating Who You Are 3. Communicating Who theCompany is -- Branding 4. Transmitting Values 5. Fostering Collaboration 6. Taming the Grapevine 7. Sharing Knowledge 8. Leading People into the Future
![]() |
| Hon. Loren Legarda, senator of the Philippines |
![]() |
| Gender equality and empowerment of women and children, one of the platforms of His Excellency Benigno Simeon Cojuangco Aquino III President of the Republic of the Philippines, 2010-2016. |
- Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger
- Achieve universal primary education
- Promote gender equality and empower women
- Reduce child mortality
- Improve maternal health
- Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases
- Ensure environmental sustainability and
- Develop a global partnership for development.
Reduce by half the proportion of people who suffer from hunger
To achieve universal primary education Ensure that all boys and girls complete a full course of primary schooling To promote gender equality and empower women Eliminate gender disparity in primary/secondaryeducationpreferably by2005, andatalllevelsby 2015 To reduce child mortality Reduce by two third the mortality rate among children under five To improve maternal health Reduce by three quarters the maternal mortality ratio To combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases To halt and begin to reverse the spread of HIV/AID To halt and begin to reverse the incidence of malaria and other major diseases To ensure environmental sustainability To integrate the principles of sustainable development into countrypoliciesandprograms;reverseloss of environmental resource To reduce by half the proportion of people without sustainable access to safe drinking water To achieve significant improvement in lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers by 2020 To develop a global partnership for development To develop further an open trading and financial system that is rule based, predictable and non-discriminatory, including a commitment to good governance, development and poverty reduction nationally and internationally To address the least developed countries specific needs, including tariff and quota free access for their exports, enhanced debt relief for heavily indebted poor countries, cancellation of official bilateral debt, and more generous official development assistance for countries committed to poverty reduction To address the special needs of landlocked and small island developing states To deal comprehensively with developing countries debt problems through national and international measures, to make debt sustainable in the long terms In cooperation with pharmaceutical companies, to provide access to affordable essential drugs in developing countries In cooperation with the private sector, to make available the benefits of new technologies especially information and communications technologies. By the year 2015, all 189 United Nations member states have pledged to meet the above mentioned goals. (http://www.un.org/millennium goals/) (Images and YouTube videos in accordance with doctrine of Fair Use, sec. 107 Title 17, US Code, Copyright Law -- For criticism, comment, teaching, scholarship and research, for non profit educational purpose.)![]() |
| Dream High, a metafiction Korean TV drama dares to take up sexual harassment and suicide |
It is our position then that we have the mandate, to empower girls and women in Asia and Africa. One of the ways by which we can empower girls and women in Asia and Africa is by Knowledge/Understanding generation, by teachingboth the theory of feminist philosophy and the practice of empowerment, through the lenses of Systems Theory/Thinking.
I have been teaching feminist theory for the past thirty years. I have taught other philosophy subjects, like logic, dialectics, philosophical psychology, ethics, aesthetics, hermeneutics, cultural studies, Oriental culture andstudies, specifically Indian studies for the past forty years. I teach Feminism as a core subject. And even when I am not teaching Feminist Philosophy as core, I always try to include Empowerment of Women in any and all the subjects that I teach. And the transformation of my students, both female and male, in consciousness raising, commitment and compassion is total. I still have to meet a student of mine, who has not gone through some kind of conversion narrative.
Perhaps it is really my advocacy. For beneath everything that I write, teach and do, throughout all my scholarships and travels, I have seen and experienced the political, economic, social, religiousand cultural status of women in Asia and Africa, and how there is a need to make Asian and African women more conscious of their civil liberties, human rights and oppressive status. DEFINITION OF TERMS
According to Kate Millet in her doctoral dissertation and book "Sexual Politics" (1970), there is a difference between Sex and Gender: Sex is biological, physiological, natural. Sex cannot really be changed, except most probably in transsexual operation, which is an altogether different issue. Lately, however, cutting edge research is also trying to see if there is a DNA exclusive to heterosexuality or homosexuality. Still, Sex is either male or female, according to what nature has given a person. Gender is environmental, social, cultural. There is nothing really tautological between male and masculine, female and feminime. It is possible for the female to be masculine or the male to be feminime. A person is born either male or female, but bred as masculine or feminime. It is culture and society which breeds the masculine or feminime. The core gender identity of a person begins by age eighteen months. (Kate Millet, "Theory of Sexual Politics in Radical Feminism", ed. Barbara A. Crow, New York: New York University Press, 2000, pp. 122-153) According to Margaret W. Matlin in the "Psychology of Women" (2008), "the terms sex and gender have provoked considerable controversy". Sex isa narrow term; refers to inborn biological characteristics relating to reproduction, such as sex chromosomes or sex organs. Gender is a broader term; refers to psychological characterisitcs and social categories. (Margaret W.Matlin, "The Psychology of Women". United States: Thomson Wansworth, 2008 , pp. 3-4) While, according to Kari Elisabeth Borresen in "Subordination and Equivalence", a pioneering classic work, genderedness is in the sense of interaction between biologically determined sex and culturally expressed gender, as the main analytical category. Since this new methodology serves to investigate both female and male existence, the focus is now on Gender Studies." (Kari Elisabeth Borresen, "Subordination and Equivalence: The Nature and Role of Woman in Augustine and Thomas Aquinas" Kampen, the Netherlands: Kok Pharos Publishing House, 1995, p. xxi) THE PRESENT CONTEXT
According to the Oxford English Dictionary, discrimination is defined as the act of discriminating or distinguishing a distinction (made with the mind or in action); the power of observing differences accurately, or making exact definitions.Since the mid 1950s in the United States of America, however, the word discrimination has acquired an exclusive negative shading, because of its politically loaded use as a term of condemnation. Discrimination has quickly acquired the following meaning: unfair and reprehensible behavior towards a representative of a given race, religion, ethnic group, sex, or behavioral dysfunction.
Lately, it is legally actionable for a citizen to notice or comment upon the distinguishing characteristic of some offended group, even if no unfair action follows, according to George Sunderland, a policy analyst in Washington D. C. in his paper, Discrimination and Differentiation: An Ethical Biological Issue.
We observe that God, however we define Him in different religions and philosophies, has given man and woman the ability to discriminate, to distinguish between good and evil, between right and wrong.
But man and woman, individually and as a collective, have made used of discrimination, instead to discriminate between class, caste, race, age, sex, gender, commit such injustices as clericalism, militarism, imperialism, environmental degradation.![]() |
| BanZhao 45-116 CE |
Consider the oppression and discrimination of girls and women in Asia and Africa, for instance.
In India, despite the Indian Independence Act, declared on August 15, 1947; and the Constitution of India institutionalized on January 26, 1950, that also protects human rights of women, bans the payment of a marriage dowry, and the practice of suti or the wife jumping into the pyre of a dead husband, there is still the common practice of the dowry system, bride burning or murder, sex discrimination in favor of the male and a bias against the female, abortion and sterilization.
In China, there is discrimination in the work place, abortion of female fetuses, preference for boys and men in the family.
In Japan, there is the male oriented emperor system, where only the male can inherit the imperial throne, there are deadly hazards to the health of women, by a highly dangerous technology, there is child abuse and child prostitution.
In Korea, there is still the division between North Korea and South Korea, and the landmines in between that endanger the lives of children and women, there is militarism, and the unwritten law that the male is the absolute master in life. Recently, there is a string of suicides among the movie and entertainment Hallyu industry, because of depression, stress and a fast-paced public life, making Korea with the highest rate of suicidesamong OECD countries. Six out of nine suicides are women.
In Malaysia and Indonesia, there is religious fundamentalism, worsening communal relations and diminished political freedom.
In the Philippines and Thailand, there is job discrimination, factory health hazards including child labor, human trafficking, sometimes sex tourism, institutional prostitution, abandonment of children, hostage taking, kidnapping, torture and rape. In Africa, there is genital mutilation, economic and political disparity, the question of the role and rights of women, Negritude, hybridity, apartheid, diaspora, the problem of nationhood, racism, tribalism, punishment, torture, war crimesand genocide.![]() |
| MurasakiShikibu 972-1014or 1025 |
Thus, I would like to suggest a VMOKRAPI about Empowerment of Women. VMOKRAPI means Vision, Mission, Objectives, Key Result Areas and Performance Indicators, as taught at theAsianInstitute of Management in Makati, Philippines.The knowledge and skill of decision makers, strategic planners and tactical actionists in VMOKRAPI would help immensely in making an agenda or curriculum or projects on empowerment of women more goal targeted, strategically planned, efficient and effective. I have used Systems Thinking to provide structure to VMOKRAPI. John Pourdehnad, Ph. D. of the Ackoff Center for Advancement of Systems Approaches (ACASA), professor at Wharton School, and the Center of Organizational Dynamics of the School of Arts and Sciences, Graduate School of the University of Pennsylvania, suggests that Idealized Design requires three iterations of four major steps, as follows: 1. Creating a mission statement (Purposeor role the systems play initscontaining environment) 2. Identifying the functions of a system (Output) 3. Formulating the processes of doing the work (how they do what they do) 4. Organizing the structure to do the work (major actors) (Michael C. Jackson, Systems Thinking, Creative Holism for Managers, 2003 p. 170) VISION The Vision of this project is: To transform women and girls into leaders, partners and team players towards
Equality, Development and Peace in Asia and Africa.
(Equality, Development and Peace is the Vision of the UNESCO Statement on Womens Contribution to a Culture of Peace, Fourth World Conference on Women, Beijing, China, 4-15 September 1995)
As a corollary: To put an empowered woman in every home, school, workplace.
MISSION
The Mission of the Philosophy of Education for Women in Asia and Africa is:
To advocate that women achieve full equality with men through suffrage, civil rights and human rights.
To advocate that women end slavery and share in the development goals of men in economics and business world.
To advocate that women be part of the decision making and involvement with the peace process and environmental concerns.
That there is a need for nothing less than total transformation of the world, particularly in Asia and Africa, for full acceptance of women.
For a woman may learn to empower herself, each and every woman in Asia and Africa may be empowered in 100 years, but if the other half of humanity cannot accept it, if men do not acknowledge the empowerment of women, there is really no genuine equality.
It is like the Northern Union of the United States of America, declaring the freedom of slaves, and the abolition of slavery during the Civil War, which Abraham Lincoln won, but without acceptance from the Southern Confederacy. When the North declared that the whole union is greater than one state, the South simply ceded from the union.
Thus, emancipation can only be fully realized if all people acknowledge and recognize the covenant. Until such time, there is really no genuine equality.
OBJECTIVES/ CORE VALUES
Our Vision/Mission is a world totally transformed particularly in Asia and Africa where women and men are politically, economically and socially equal to each other.
Our Objectives are threefold:
- Self Development
- Development of Knowledge and Skills
- Communicative Action
I. For Self Development to happen:
- There must be Development of Self Identity or a definition of the self towards self worth and self respect.
- There must be Development of Independence, based on the physical, emotional, and financial independence of women
- There must be Fearlessness.
II. For Development of Knowledge and Skills to happen;
- A Philosophy subject can go through the Feminist Theory and History of Feminism both in the West and East
- A Philosophy subject can go through the History of the Asian and African country, emphasizing the lessons learned from colonization.
- A Philosophy subject can go through ancient philosophical texts, where women have self identity, where there is equality of status between male and female, where women are fearless, like in the Upanishads, Mahabharata, Bhagavad Gita, Ramayana; Dao de Jing ( Tao Te Ching) attributed to Lao Zi (Lao Tzu), Zhuangzi (Chuang Tzu), the Analects by Confucius (Kongfuzi/ Kung Fu Tzu), The Art of War by Sun Tze; Zen Buddhism by Daisetz Suzuki, the songs and poetry of ancient Japan and Korea; the Quran, of Islam Malaysia and Indonesia; Ramakien of Thailand; the letter to the Women of Malolos, Noli Me Tangere and El Filibusterismo, all written by Jose Rizal, national hero of the Philippines, the letter to Noynoy Aquino and siblings, Ballsy, Pinky, Viel and Krisby Benigno Aquino Jr., national martyr of the Philippines; the Epic of Sundiata in Medieval Mali, the Epic of Dinga in Ghana, the Book of Kings from Ethiopia, the animal trickters stories from Africa.
III. For Fearlessness to happen:
- There must be a working out of relationships with the family, resolving definitions of role and expectations as wife in sexual encounters, and as mother in kinship structures.
- There must be a working out of relationships with the community, in terms of sisterhood, support and networking.
- There must be a working out of relationships to nature through the Peace Process and Sustainable Ecology.
- Finally, there must be an integration of all these nine key areas in the Female, towards a whole and entire and new Personhood.
An empowered female is a person who has the capacity to counter the power over others, with the countervailing power over the self or self autonomy.
An empowered woman in every home, school and workplace!
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS
These ten KEY RESULT AREAS, must have corresponding PERFORMANCE INDICATORS to test the viability and success of programs towards gender equality and empowerment of women. From the very beginning, the performance indicators must be SMART, meaning specific, measurable, accurate, realistic and time bound.
For example, the United Nations Millennium Development Goals, corresponding to the Third Goal, which is to promote gender equality and empower women, indicate as one Performance Indicator the following:
To eliminate gender disparities in primary and secondary education preferably by 2005 and at all levels, primary, secondary and tertiary education by 2015.
The Performance Indicator here is SMART: specific, measurable, accurate, realistic and certainly timebound. So if by 2005, a country among the 189 signatories, still has gender disparity in primary and secondary education, the Key Result Area can be considered as a failure in social justice. Indeed, many countries have failed in this Key Result Area in 2010.So if by 2015, the country still has gender disparity in primary, secondary and tertiary levels, again the program is a failure in social justice.
On the one hand, according to the United Nations Development Programme, as of 2003: Two third of illiterates are women, and the rate of employment among women is two thirds of men. The proportion of seats in parliaments held by women is increasing, reaching about one third in Argentina, Mozambique and South Africa.
(http://www.undp.org/mdg) On the other hand, for the past ten years since 2000: there is significant progress in the Millennium Development Goals in Asia and the Pacific, according to UN Millennium Campaign Regional Director Minar Pimple -- as far as the fourth, sixth and seventh goals, specifically reducing child mortality, combating malaria, and ensuring environmental sustainability, like access to safe drinking water. But in the Philippines, 33% of about 92 million Filipinos still live on less than US $1 a day; 5.2 million children are out of school; 11 mothers die each day due to pregnancy related causes. The incidence of HIV/ AIDS among the youth have increased five-fold, from 41 in 2007 to 218 in 2009. (I would like to note that the five fold increase may be statistically correct; but, the interpretationseems out of context, misleadingand should be questioned.) The Philippines is way behind targets particularly in poverty, education, maternal health. President Benigno Simeon Aquino IIIhasattended the Millennium Summit for the MDGs at the United Nations on 20-22 September 2010. The Philippines is the recipient of US $ 434 Million from the MillenniumChallenge Corporation. But a breakdown of how the funds would be spent shows that 214.4 Million dollars are to build and repair 270 km. of the Samar Road; 120 Million dollars for water systems. clinics and schools; 54.3 Million dollars to computerize and steamline the business process in the Bureau of Internal Revenue. How computers, which eventually will be out of date and obsolete in five to ten years, can feed the33 millionFilipinos in absolute poverty living on US $ 1.25 a day, and still prevent maternal and children's mortality and diseases, isbeyond the imagination. The bonanza of US $ 434 Million can buy434 millionhotdogs and hamburgers, preferably the local longganiza, to string around7000 islands in the Philippines, seven thousand times over and back. The delegation accompanying President Aquino included only three businesswomen and few female staff. Just as Aquino's cabinet hasseven women and twenty men; so there is really no gender parity.A lack of representation of women and MDG advocates results in de-feminization of the MDGs. When men plan for the basic needs of women, the result can be disaster.Men usually buy electronic gadgets first before food. This is in contrast to all the policies and programs, specially"ChileCrece Contigo"or "Chile Grows With You" of President Michelle Bachelet in Chile.THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK: A MODEL FOR EMPOWERMENT
There is a need to coach women and girls towards an empowered self. The need for a three stage development of Self, Independence and Fearlessness is based upon an understanding of the philosophy of power and power relations. (Woman and Religion, A Collection of Essays, Personal Histories and Contextualized Liturgies, Ed.: Sr. Mary John Mananzan, Manila: Institute of Womens Studies, St. Scholasticas College, 1988 211 pp.)
![]() |
| Corazon Cojuangco Aquino 1933-2009 |
![]() |
| Fearless Cory and Benigno Aquino Jrbefore a military tribunal. |
Case Statement One: Power is not a substance that walks up and down the street. Power is an accident, property or attribute called relation. Power is one of nine accidents in contrast to the one self sufficient Substance in the Categories of Aristotle.
Case Statement Two: Power requires a power sender, and a power receiver.
The power sender, by virtue of position and/or resources, is able to exercise effective power over another, called power receiver. The power sender acts as superior to the power receiver acting as inferior.
There are three kinds of power:
- Normative power based on persuasion
- Remuneration based on bargaining
- Punitive power based on force
- For persuasion to work, submissiveness is necessary
- For bargaining to work, dependence is necessary
- For force to work, an element of fear is necessary
For example:
- Racism race and ethnic derivatives
- Ageism age
- Sexism gender
- Clericalism class
- Militarism class
- Imperialism -- class
- Environmental degradation
Case Statement Five: Thus, Empowerment of girls and women involves the capacity of a female to counter power over the other, with a countervailing power over the self or self autonomy.
- To answer the abuse of normative power by persuasion, the female must build a self identity and self respect
- To answer remunerative power by bargaining, the female must develop self sufficiency in the physical, emotional and financial aspects.
- To answer punitive power by force, the female must develop fearlessness.
An empowered woman in every home, school and work place!
First she must inoculate herself against the power sender, and
Second, she must refuse to be power receiver.
![]() |
| Aung San Suu Kyi 1945 |
To do so, we suggest a PROCESS, a module on self mastery as follows:
MODULE ONE: SELF MASTERY
1. Who am I?
2. What makes me happy?
3. So am I a philosopher?
4. Am I a feminime, feminist, female, feminalist philosopher?
5. What makes me decide to be a feminist?
6. What are the qualities that I have that fit a feminist philosopher?
7. What are the qualities that I do not have that a feminist should have?
8. What are the philosophical qualities that I should have, whether I am feminime, feminist, female, feminalist philosopher?
9. Am I an honorary feminist male philosopher?
10. Am I a male feminime, feminist, female philosopher?
By answering such questions, the female or male can realize if she or he has ownership of feminism, whether she or he has endurance, risk, competence and control in working for the empowerment of girls and women.
This module also deals with philosophy by women and philosophy about women. It aims to encourage students to think critically about how womens experience and subjectivity may challenge some fundamental assumptions regarding human nature, public and private life, subjectivity and representation. We explore how these challenges to philosophy may be met. For example, in the Talmud and the Bible, Matthew I, the genealogy of Jesus includes four women -- Tamar, Rahab, the wife of Uriah or Bathesheba, and Ruth. Tamar, a Canaanite, is a harlot or prostitute on an incestuous relationship with Judah. Rahab, another Canaanite, is also a harlot or prostitute on an illicitrelationship with Salmon. Bathsheba, the wife of Uriah, is on an adulterous relationship with David. Even Ruth, a Moabite, an ideal daughter in law to Naomi, is shown as seducing sometimes. But these four women are females with their own self-identity and self-respect, strong and independent, creative and innovative, fearless with vision/mission in crisis management and decision making! The life and writings of women e.g. Aspasia (400 BCE), Hypatia (365-415), Wu Chao (625-705), Murasaki Shikibu (978-1030), Hildegaard von Bingen (1098-1179), Christine de Pisan (1364-1430), Joan of Arc (1412-1431), Mary Wollstonecraft (1759-1797), Elizabeth Cady Stanton (1815-1902), Margaret Mead (1901-1978), Simone de Beauvoir (1908-1986), Indira Gandhi (1917-1984), Iris Murdock (1919-1999), Betty Friedan (1921-2006), Mary Daly (1928), Luce Irigaray (1930), Corazon Aquino (1933-2009), Kate Millet (1934), Gloria Steinem (1934), Helene Cixous (1937), Germaine Greer (1939), Elaine Showalter (1941), Julia Kristeva (1941), Gayatri Chakraworty Spivak (1942), Aung San Suu Kyi (1945), Graca Machel (1945), Catherine MacKinnon (1946), Andrea Dworkin (1946), Martha Nussbaum (1947), Patricia Williams (1951), Judith Butler (1956) comprise a significant component because they insist on taking seriously womens experiences, voices and potentialities. Students may use these story-telling, readings and discussions to reflect critically about their own journey and experiences as men and women who live in a gendered world, and to think through the consequences of the problem of women.
![]() |
| Indira Nehru Gandhi 1917-1984 |
MODULE TWO: HISTORY OF FEMINISM Case Statement: More than any discourse, mode of criticism, ethics or aesthetics, feminist critique has cut across and drawn on multiple and contradictory traditions, while presenting the most fundamental challenge to critical orthodoxies. It has two core values: its revaluation of subjectivity and category of experience. Overview: Although women have been active philosophers for many centuries, the feminist viewpoint in philosophy has gained credence only recently; as a result of widespread debates about sexual politics and of social and economic changes in the status of women. The strands of feminist thinking in philosophy continue to be diverse and do not present a unified point of view. Feminist approaches to philosophy takes place at a number of levels and from different perspectives. This may be identified as a notable strength. For example, feminists have presented philosophical critiques of philosophers' images of women, political critiques of the organization of the discipline of philosophy, critiques of philosophy as masculine, historical research into the work of past women philosophers whose work may have been unjustly disregarded, and positive contributions to philosophy from a feminist perspective. Core Ideas. 1. Early feminist criticism drew extensively on Simone de Beauvoir's "The Second Sex", 1949, a work which initiated process of analysing social construction of gender and distinguishing between sex and gender. It also drew on Kate Millett's "Sexual Politics", 1970, which analyzed system of sex-role stereotyping and oppression of women under patriarchial social organization. 2. Feminist criticism in 1960's and 1970's analyzed images of women represented in or constructed through cultural forms as literature and art. But it did not question the category of literature itself or the dominant expressive mimetic aesthetics. It did not analyze the relationship between ideology and representation and thus inadvertently affirming universalism and subjectivism of traditional liberal humanist criticism. 3. Feminist criticism studies the text through an analysis of the specific articulations of patriarchy within capitalist society. It situates the text in relation to an analysis, for example, of the economic position of women as a consequence of the division of labour and organization of the family; the effects on female authorship and reading habits; the role of cultural forms in this process and the specific organization of the institution according to masculine discourses and valuations. 4. There is increasing attention from broadly liberal to broadly socialist or radical feminists to texts by women as opposed to study of representation of women in texts by male authors. This approach is explicitly advocated by Elaine Showalter as basis of Gynocriticism. Her book, "A Literature of their Own", 1977, attempted to construct an alternative tradition of women's writing, focusing specifically on female writing and experience. Although her work challenged sexist bias of liberal tradition, it failed to challenge its fundamental conception of subject and text. 5. If subjectivity is conceived in essential and unitary terms; tradition remains a continuous and seamless process, and the text remains imbedded in an expressive mimetic aesthetic. If it reaffirms orthodox humanist belief in art as expression of a universal unity encompassing men and women, known as human nature, this category is simply enlarged rather than undermined or deconstructed.
6. "A Literature of Their Own" calls Feminime, Feminist and Female stages, the patterns and phases in the evolution of female tradition, which correspond to developmental phases of any subcultural art.
7. During the Feminime phase, dating 1840 to 1880, women wrote in an effort to equal intellectual achievements of male culture and internalize assumptions about female nature.
In Feminist phase, from 1880 to 1920, or the winning of the vote, women are historically enabled to reject accommodating postures of femininity and use art to dramatize ordeals of wronged womanhood. This is Feminist Socialist Realism.
In Female Phase, ongoing since 1920, women reject both imitation and protest, two forms of dependency, and turn to female experience as source of autonomous art, extending feminist analysis of culture to forms and techniques. This celebration of consciousness is formal Female Aesthetics. Lately, a Feminalist Phase has been suggested. Georgia Duerst-Lahti defines feminalism as "an ideology that begins from and prefers that which is associated with feminality, the feminale and females".Feminalism is a broad gender ideology that provides an overarching grand metanarrative for further analysis of institutional norms, practices, assumptions, preferences; rather than merely the superiority and dominance of the masculine ormale, and the inferiority and subordination ofthe feminime or female.Martha Nussbaum's cutting edge research on the Politics of Disgust, Women and Human Development, Frontiers of Justice, Disability, Nationality, Species Membership, Sexual Orientation and Same-Sex Marriage can be under this metanarrative. Postmodern Feminism critiques the male and female binary and argues against this polarity as the organizing force of society. It advocates a deconstructionof blurring boundaries between male and female, eliminating dichotomies and accepting multiple realities. Postcolonial Feminism rejects colonial power relationships where the colonizer strips the colonized of her customs, traditions and values. Third World Feminism focuses on capitalism as shaping all relationships of dominance, how oppression of women by men is similar to oppression of third world countries by first world countries. 8. Feminist criticism can be divided into two distinct varieties. The first type is concerned with woman as reader, with woman as the consumer of male produced literature and with which the hypothesis of a female reader changes apprehension of a given text, awakening to the significance of sexual codes. This is called feminist critique. It is a historically grounded inquiry which probes ideological assumptions of art and cultural phenomena. Its subjects include images and stereotypes of women, omissions and misconceptions about women, and fissures in male constructed history. It also concerns with exploitation and manipulation of female audience, specially in popular culture and film and with analysis of woman as sign in semiotic systems. 9. The second type of feminist criticism is concerned with woman as writer, with woman as producer of textual meaning, history, themes, genres and structures of art by women. Its subjects include psychodynamics of female creativity, linguistics and problem of female language, trajectory of individual or collective female career, art history and studies of particular artists and works. No term exists in English for such specialized discourse, so the French term: Gynocritique. 10. Feminist critique is essentially political and polemical, with theoretical affiliations to Marxist sociology and aesthetics. Gynocritics is more self contained and experimental, with connections to other modern or new feminist research. Feminist critique instills feminist consciousness while Gynocritique renders conversions narratives. It is amazing how high the moral tone both take, while drawing insights from structuralist Marxism, psychoanalysis and deconstruction.![]() |
| Women and Human Development |
![]() |
| Martha Nussbaum, Ph. D., professor at University of Chicago one of top female philosophers of the 21st century |
![]() |
| From Disgust to Humanity, 2010 on Politics of Disgust, sexual orientation and same sex marriage |
2. Although women tend to work in this area, not all women philosophers are necessarily feminist philosophers, although there may be feminist implications in their work.
Questions Have Answers
1. One central question for feminist philosophers has been the extent to which philosophy is biased towards a masculine viewpoint, when the majority of past philosophers have been men. Can philosophy be trusted to be neutral on the question of sexual difference? It may be a historical accident that philosophy has been an activity associated with men. If, however, it is more deeply permeated with masculine values, feminists ask whether such values are indelibly or contingently imprinted into the practice of philosophy. Such questions implicate the basis of philosophy itself. Notions of reason, truth, and knowledge, and the way that philosophical inquiries often seem to fall into distinctions of mind-body, order-chaos, or rely on hierarchies of terms, are called into question.
2. Feminists also point out that such distinctions often map on to, or presuppose, sexual difference, aligning masculinity with reason and order. This issue is of significance because it has bearing on topics such as personhood or self-identity and epistemology. If the association of reason with masculinity is reinforced by social structures, then a particular type of experience is being validated at the expense of other possible viewpoints, and such a bias should be corrected.
Problems Have Solutions:
1. But problems arise in trying to assess where exactly the bias lies: which aspects of experience belong to which sex; to what extent such differences, if identified, belong contingently or properly to each sex; whether men and women see the world very differently and whether they are very different persons.
2. These issues are often expressed in terms of a distinction between sex and gender where sex is the biologically invariant factor and gender is comprised of social, cultural, or historical variable components. Other ways in which the division has been expressed are as nature-culture, or male-masculine and female-feminine. But making such distinctions does not necessarily resolve all the problems.
3. In the past it has been argued that sex creates or causes gender, i.e. that biology shapes cultural perceptions of difference. But this view has been objected to if it seems to result in a deterministic account of identity which cannot allow for the transformation of perceptions of difference, or attributes essentially different identities or ways of thinking to men and women. Essential difference is not necessarily a problem, but differences may be given unequal value such that women are seen as "the weaker sex".
4. A milder version of the above argument would allow that biological difference contributes to perceptions of difference but is not the only factor, and so cannot be wholly determining. Differences could then be minimized and some equality established. Difference would not disappear altogether, but, with equality of opportunity, would not be used prejudicially against one sex. Thinkers such as Millett and de Beauvoir suggest this approach.
5. However, ideas of equality may already have been shaped in a particular way, based on notion.
The emphasis of Feminist Criticism and Gynocritics is the new female/feminalist in an environment of equality, freedom and collective support, becoming whole and well-integrated, finding self identity and meaning of existence, in ones own consciousness and experience, and not only in sexual relationships or kinship structures.
MODULE THREE: VMOKRAPI
Thus, as a Performance Indicator to gender equality and empowerment of women, we recommend the following:
The Key Result Areas (KRA) by 2015 should indicate a partial liberation of women, meaning:
- Education ofninety percent of girls from primary grades to secondary grades by 2015
- Education ofeighty percent of girls and women in college
- Employment ofseventy percent of women.
Thus, the performance indicators (PI) can be quantitatively and qualitatively analyzed.
I have personally discovered that personal liberation cannot be attained without the socio-cultural context. One cannot work from a vacuum. One has to work with STRUCTURE, with the cultures, philosophies and religions of students and countries where one is teaching.
STRUCTURAL/INSTITUTIONAL CHANGE
There is a threefold stage in change management of the institution or system or organization:
consciousness raising or education towards liberation
consciousness raising in human relationships, between male and female, between superiorand inferior, between old and young, between polarities in general consciousness raising in the peace process, and the environment PERSONAL CHANGE There are three stages in changing a person, in self development, based upon three basic concepts.The material conditions for liberation
The problem of alienation
The method of dialectic thought.
1) Material Conditions for Liberation
When we discuss liberation, we cannot just talk about an abstract idea, we must talk about actual potential or possibilities rooted in reality.
The possibility of womens liberation exists because the material conditions of the world, new technology, and human rightshave evolved so much that there is no longer any need for oppression and the secondary status of women.
By material conditions, we mean, that information technology, scientific discoveries on the human brain, industrialization, liberalization, globalizationand the new economic system which defines the way human beings relate to each other.
For example, many religions perpetuate abusive concepts; like the myth of Adam and Eve, and the fall of man as caused by Eve, or the Orthodox morning prayer thanking God that he was not born a woman.
These myths have to be processed with the students.
2) The Problem of Alienation
In the capitalist society, alienation has three forms:
People are alienated from their work; because, they do not receive full benefits produced by their labor. Women juggling between home and career are overworked and underpaid. Theyremain invisible. Women who have worked all their lives as wives and mothers have no social security benefits and Medicaid. People are alienated from each other; because, they compete for survival and success. The alienation between sexes is the key to this social alienation in which people see themselves as isolated units and women are objects of pleasure. Men and women feel alienated in the world where they see each other as competitors, and the opposite as dominant or inferior. Alienation from nature. Instead of resources of nature being used for the benefits of all people, natural and human resources are ravaged for the benefit of a few. As Martha Nussbaum says, every man/woman is born equal and with equal capabilities. Together with Nobel Prize Laureate in economics, Amartya Sen and his new insightful definition of "poverty", Nussbaum and her"theory of capabilities" is thecorrect interpretation of the right to life and equal opportunities. According to Nussbaum, every man/woman has the right to live to old age, to equal economic opportunities, and exercise of political rights. 3) The Method of Dialectic Thought Yet every woman must be conscious of Hegel's Dialectical Thought, the capacity of a female to make a leap from inequality to equality, from poverty to liberation, from oppression to empowerment. Contradiction exists in the process of development. For example, in personality development, we are both being and becoming. At the moment of development, we begin to grow, as well as to die. All processes involve change of motion. Change occurs through interaction of contradictions and conflict.Change occurs because a given concept is challenged by its opposite, and a synthesis occurs which is unlike either conflicting idea, which has the strengths of both, and cancels out the weaknesses of either. The search for self identity and meaning, the two basic problems of the 21st century, can be resolved in the reconciliation of opposites -- the yang and yin, the atman and Brahman of ancient civilizations, the self and the collective of contemporary times. Our Herstory has evolved and progressed because humans have acquired new knowledge, new technology and progressive laws which contradict earlier formulations. The struggle between the old and new results in a different understanding of the world and of ourself. Now it is the "New Normal". CALL TO ACTION Thus, an Idealized Designof Systems Thinking inthree iteration with four steps must be applied and assessed again and again until the global millennium goals are totally achieved by 2015, by 2020, and beyond that. 1) Creating a vision/mission statement 2) Identifying the functions of a system 3) Formulating the processes of doing the work 4) Organizing the structure to do the work. Post Script But William S. Wilkinsky, Ph. D. in Psychology, Coaching Graduate Studies leader at the University of Pennsylvania, eminent guru of coaching women, girlsand executives, tells us that based on his experience, even a very large amount of structural change causes only a small amount of personal change! Governments and leaders are changed; plans and promises are put aside.War, violence, terrorism disrupt development. While when a particular man and/or woman is touched, changed from within and empowered from without, he/she carries it forward to the next family, organization or environment. Letour visionthen becomean act of story telling. Letour dream tell its own story. Indeed, towards an empowered woman in every home, school and workplace. One person, one village or baranggay. One country at a time.
Work From Home Jobs Sunderland News
Marathon bus cheat gets job ... on the busses - The Sun
14 May 2012 at 6:55pm Mr Sloan, of Downhill, Sunderland ... job I?ve ever had. ?I got it because of my reputation for being a good mechanic. ?The people I work with have all been very supportive and good company as well.? Mr Sloan has also kept up his fitness by running ...Read more...
Match report: Fulham 2 Sunderland 1 - Shields Gazette
7 May 2012 at 10:42am SUNDERLAND are now on their longest winless run of the season ? longer than the one which cost Steve Bruce his job back in December ... Minds have already turned ? his own included ? to the work to be done in the close season. And this defeat ...Read more...
Fulham 2 Sunderland 1: Full match report - Sunderland Echo
7 May 2012 at 6:24am SUNDERLAND are now on their longest winless run of the season ? longer than the one which cost Steve Bruce his job back in December ... Minds have already turned ? his own included ? to the work to be done in the close season. And yesterday ...Read more...
Next page: Work From Home Jobs Budeligh Salterton






.jpg)







































